Noah Smith (Brainwasher)

By Xah Lee. Date: .

Who is Noah Smith

Noah Smith tweet 2022-11-27 ZsZzC
Noah Smith tweet 2022-11-27 ZsZzC
Noah Smith face photo 2023-07-30
Noah Smith face photo 2023-07-30
Noah Smith Wikipedia 2023-07-30
Noah Smith Wikipedia 2023-07-30

Noah Smith, Quoting George Orwell Out of Context to Incite War

Noah Smith George Orwell 2023-07-30 FxjS
Noah Smith George Orwell 2023-07-30 FxjS [https://twitter.com/Noahpinion/status/1685481642989875200]
george orwell pacifist 2023-07-30 Rwmb
george orwell pacifist 2023-07-30 Rwmb

The first important thing about Orwell's quote, which comes from a Partisan Review polemic worth reading in full, is that it was written in August 1942—a time when Nazi Germany and its allies occupied all of France, Belgium, the Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Czechoslovakia, Austria, Hungary, Italy, Yugoslavia, Greece, Bulgaria, Romania, Ukraine, plus almost all of northwest Africa and most of Asia's eastern shore. There had been times since the onset of Hitler's aggressively expansionist war that England felt surrounded, besieged, and alone. If ever there was a context in which one could plausibly make the claim that pacifism is objectively pro-Fascist, it would be early 1940s England.

[Why Selectively Quoting Orwell's 'Objectively Pro-Fascist' Line Matters By Matt Welch. At https://reason.com/2014/06/18/why-selectively-quoting-orwells-objectiv/ ]